Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

preschool evaluations

I'm gonna say it again: preschool evaluations are the best. At least they are for me, a manager of engineers who need to work together. You don't even need a preschooler to understand what I'm saying, just google preschool assessment forms and see what kinds of things they are evaluated on. Yes there are the "skills" like coloring in the lines, knowing letters, pointing out which shape is the triangle. But if you're going to a good preschool the kids spend a lot of time just playing so their evaluation is based on this life-changing new question: can you handle the WORLD?

For example:
- Plays independently with minimal supervision
- Shares willingly
- Uses words to express needs
- Respects the personal space of others
- Participates in group activities
- Willing to try new things
- Invites others to join in group play

These are things that preschool teachers discuss with you at length, and then you never hear about them again. From what I've read, some parents never hear about them PERIOD, as there is more and more pressure from preschools to drill kids on mundane facts so they can recognize letters before anybody on their block and impress adults by reciting the periods of the paleozoic period.

If I had to do it over again, I might request to see an evaluation form that's used for conferences before I pick the preschool. I lucked out - the school we picked based on simple toys, degreed teachers, and cheapness evaluates mostly on social and behavioral skills with a side note about recognizing triangles. But behavior is the priority.

I read a great book, "Becoming Brilliant", about this topic. I'll blog more about it in the future but it's too big for one entry. The basic point though: we live in a world where facts are readily available, but we still value facts and content in education. Critical thinking and the ability to work in groups is on the downtrend.

I KNOW, because I work with grown ass people who cannot "use words to express needs". I love them, sometimes... anyway...

I sat in Olive's preschool evaluation hearing about how she's a bright little kid who can write her name like a pro but they're still dealing with these "meltdowns" when she doesn't use her words to say what she wants, and the teacher explained that they're working on it, but it's also a common issue with three year olds and she will grow out of it.

Let's just pretend that I'd come from a meeting with adults yelling "No you SAID YOU'D WRITE THAT REPORT IT'S NOT MY JOB" rather than declaring calmly, "here's where we are now, the deliverable isn't done, we all agree it's critical so now we just have to decide who is best equipped in this team to handle it?" All I could think was I'm not so sure everyone grows out of it. We just assume it's handled when you're three feet tall and never speak of it again.

I think we should keep working on those skills, everyone.

Recent Posts from This Journal

  • the great flood

    last summer we really got in the habit of letting the kids have "sister sleepover" in the basement every night, lazing around down there until who…

  • june road trip

    this past week was full of family adventures, I'm home sitting on my own couch finally and thrilled to be here! It was an awesome time though. last…

  • stock market

    Found out that my old scottrade account, now TD Ameritrade, was still open. I had $616.41 sitting in it. I swore off stock trading when my shares of…


( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
Apr. 15th, 2017 02:04 pm (UTC)
I think this behavioral evaluation would be of more use than my work's current performance review system.

(My job would be easier if we did just yell at each other and get it over with instead of the passive-aggression Olympics we currently do.)
Apr. 15th, 2017 04:33 pm (UTC)
You're right, preschool evaluations based on behaviors sound like they should be continued well into adulthood.
Apr. 15th, 2017 09:08 pm (UTC)
Apr. 15th, 2017 09:09 pm (UTC)
oh I found the actual like button :-)
Apr. 16th, 2017 03:05 am (UTC)
Grading myself (age 79):
- Plays independently with minimal supervision: Highly competent in this skill.
- Shares willingly: Needs work.
- Uses words to express needs: Is showing signs of regressing in this area.
- Respects the personal space of others: Sometimes needs cautioning about others' boundaries.
- Participates in group activities: Usually participates.
- Willing to try new things: Is still hesitant; needs encouragement frequently.
- Invites others to join in group play. Does so except when over-tired.
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

July 2019
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow