?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

banned book 2: Drama by Raina Telgemeier

Drama by Raina Telgemeier got to be Book 2 on my year of reading banned books. The order I am reading them is based on availability at my public library. Luckily this book was readily available, in the childrens section. It's a graphic novel. That's the other reason I wanted to read it, apparently this graphic novel genre has become quite the thing and I have never read one.

Basic story: Callie is a 7th grade girl who loves working on the stage crew for her school's theater department. She's got mad skills in set design. She also gets crushes on boys, befriends new kids, has victories and defeats, stays true to herself and her friends.

If I was a middle schooler I'd like this book, it's cute. I like that Callie throws herself into things she's passionate about, like many theater kids, her creativity is an outlet when the middle school drama is illogical.

As an adult I wouldn't call this book a must-read. It doesn't have any huge life lessons. I had a hard time keeping track of the characters, that's my only criticism. But the book is good for kids and graphic novels seem like a fun, easy way for them to get excited about reading. The author has also done graphic versions of babysitters club books - that's about the intellectual level we're talking about here, light stories about kids getting crushes on each other, getting in fights and making up with friends, that's it.

I was confused about why this book is on the banned books list. It has a gay character and at one point he kisses a boy, in another scene he sits on the steps with a boy he has a crush on and they talk to each other. Callie kisses a boy - and also stops a boy from kissing her in an awesome "she's smart and independent" scene that I love. Sex is not even mentioned. The characters are theater nerds: they work on stagecrew design issues and go to bookstores together. So I wasn't sure why it got banned... is it just that there's a gay character?

Amazon 1-star reviews reveal that YUP, it's because there is a gay character! These are great, guys:

http://www.amazon.com/product-reviews/0545326990/ref=acr_search_hist_1?ie=UTF8&filterBy=addOneStar&showViewpoints=0

Apparently people are shocked that a book marketed towards 5th graders contains boys who have crushes on other boys, several reviewers say that kids are not ready to handle this "mature" topic.

Heterosexual dating is okay, but same-sex relationships require more maturity.

In a way I guess I agree with them, since my whole life I've thought that people who accepted same-sex relationships were indeed a lot more mature than people who were squicked out by them. But "maturity" in that sense has nothing to do with age. I promise, the only 5th graders who can't handle this topic are the ones with over-conservative parents.

Maybe that's the problem - this book features characters who are more mature than the morons on amazon reviewing the book. Gay people just show up as part of the normal population and there's no controversy, the school isn't struck down like sodam and gomorrah, stop the presses! To me, it's exactly how I like to see diversity portrayed... minorities living their lives. The most notable thing about the gay kid isn't that he's gay, it's that he's really talented, that's what the story is about and that's what Callie admires about him. His sexual orientation is not an issue for her. The homosexual agenda in this book is just homosexuals existing. Pretty boring.

Conclusion: this book is shocking if you are from the 1940s or something, so today's 5th graders are going to be totally unaffected and just think it's fun.

Posts from This Journal by “books - banned” Tag

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
litlebanana
Feb. 6th, 2016 01:30 am (UTC)
My mother was really angry at me that I told my four-year-old daughter that women can marry other women. She said she's worried that I'm putting ideas in her head!
spacefem
Feb. 6th, 2016 02:03 am (UTC)
oh geez! she knows that's not what turns people gay, right?
litlebanana
Feb. 6th, 2016 02:54 am (UTC)
Believe it or not, she genuinely thinks that it could turn Libby gay to hear gay people exist at such a tender age. It's weird because I've never heard her say anything homophobic before, even when one of my best friends in college was gay.
fieryphoenix
Feb. 6th, 2016 03:39 pm (UTC)
I love the review lambasting the book for not warning about heterosexual content.

I fail to understand what's so difficult to explain to a child about homosexuality (I mean, I know why it's said, but I'm being rhetorical). It only needs to go as far as one's explanation of heterosexuality.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

July 2017
S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow